Review of harold kincaid, john dupre, alison wylie eds. The contributors to this volume investigate where and how values are involved in science, and examine the implications of this involvement for ideals of objectivity. The debate over whether science should be value free has shifted its. I develop an argument by indicating various aspects of the valueladenness. Values surface in numerous aspects of the scientific enterprise. Ideal or illusion kincaid, harold, dupre, john, wylie, alison. But, as often happens with babies and their bathwater, there may be something worthwhile in this slogan that we should try to identify and retain. Against the ideal of valuefree science i argue that science is notand cannot bevaluefree and that relevant values are both cognitive and moral. As recent work in the philosophy, history, and social studies of science shows, however, things are not so simple. Autonomy, asceticism, agonism max webers scientific objectivity as idea, practice and. It has long been thought that science is our best hope for realizing objective knowledge but that, to deliver on this promise, it must be free of the influence of any values that are not purely epistemic. Edited by harold kincaid, john dupre, and alison wylie.
Ideals and illusions edited by harold kincaid john dupre alison wylie oxford university press 27. Heather douglas 2007 in harold kincaid, john dupre. Alan richardson, isis a valuable anthology of essays by contemporary philosophers. This ideal of mechanical objectivity, knowledge based completely on. This timely volume edited by harold kincaid, john dupre, and alison wylie has its origins in a conference of the same name organized by kincaid at the university of alabama at birmingham in 2002. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Pdf proceedings of the 9th international conference on social. The contributors to this volume investigate where and how values are involved in. In a world without fixed types, humans are free to impose on nature. After describing the origins and nature of the valuefree ideal for science, this chapter details three challenges to the ideal. Pdf on apr 8, 2016, ivana stulec and others published proceedings of the 9th.
1326 1284 1024 479 1227 1214 1133 624 670 71 1051 155 900 520 434 1401 1033 1395 1349 575 637 1298 314 1340 445 803 131 931 528 1361 390 1426 23 416 571 627 1150 503 815 785 841 677